The Analytics Trap: Create More, Feel Worse (And a Short Author Update)

1,636 words
9 minutes read time

Blue bars decrease in height from left to right, with a curved red arrow pointing downward above them. Large black text reads, “The Analytics Trap: Create More, Feel Worse.”

I’m really tired of analytics. Really tired. WordPress updated our Stats page, adding handy little percentages to the posts that have been read for whatever time period you select. Mine is set to the seven day default, and that’s fine. I like knowing that people are reading my blogs, but I use this blog as an online journal to talk about my writing and publishing, so views don’t mean as much as the visitors I get on my author website. I love you all–you know that–but this blog doesn’t sell books. I love helping people, though, so I’ll continue posting for as long as I’m able, and I’m so glad that my tutorials like how to make a paperback cover wrap in Canva and how to upload to IngramSpark have helped authors get their books closer to publication.

Screenshot of WordPress site statistics for the last seven days, showing top blog posts, traffic sources, and visitor devices. An older Mare of Easttown article has 38 views, up 1,167%, while paperback cover tutorials lead in traffic. Search engines account for 114 referrals, and 86.9% of views come from desktop devices.

So, the new Stats page is annoying because after ten years of blogging on this site, yes, my numbers are going to go up and down. I can’t expect every blog post to have an audience every day of the week, nor do I want them to. Some of my older blog posts are so outdated that they aren’t useful anymore and I don’t want someone wasting their time.

But why do platforms continue to shove insights and analytics down our throats, especially since those platforms don’t guarantee distribution of our content?

Platforms don’t care about us. They care about giving content to their users, and that content comes from us. One more Reel. One more blog post. One more graphic. One more Live. We keep their fires burning, and we continue to toss logs on the flames hoping that we can benefit too.

Sometimes we do. A Reel goes viral and we start selling books or get a massive number of new followers. A blog post is shared and we help hundreds of people.

And that’s enough to keep us posting. Because we keep hoping that our content will reach people, and in doing so, that reach will turn into the results we want.

There’s no finish line. Just an endless churn of content. We aren’t even throwing our content into the void. A void implies nothingness. There’s too much out there and it’s a fight to be seen.

And what it does to our mindset and how we think is worth paying attention to. Low visibility or distribution can feel like our fault, and to make matters worse, sometimes it is. Audiences sometimes don’t click with what you’re putting out there, but you don’t know if that’s what it is or if the platform you’re posting on just isn’t giving your content a chance.

I was having really good luck with my Reels. Really good luck, and I was selling books. But my views have since cooled off–as I knew they would, though obviously sooner than I would have liked–and it’s tempting to post more or post something different to see if I can wiggle something loose. But I’m tired. There are, reasonably, only so many hours in the day to create content and post it. I didn’t do anything, that I know of, to make my views decrease, and I’m not going to scramble to try to get them back to where they were. I work forty hours a week. I want to play with my cat when I’m done with my shifts. I want to watch an episode of Bones before I go to bed, and I like to sleep. If what I’m doing isn’t enough anymore, there’s not a lot I can do about it, and letting it prey on my mental health will drive me crazier than I already am.

Because here’s the sad truth: The platforms have made creators feel responsible for outcomes they don’t fully control. What the algos do isn’t our fault.

Views down, post more. Engagement down, post more. But why? When there’s no guarantee that anyone is going to see those posts?

When I started posting Reels at the end of August, I used to have a Reel do well pretty regularly. I’m talking 50,000+ views. It exceeded any expectations I had, especially after being in TikTok’s 200-view dungeon. Now, in the past week or so, I can barely get them above 3,000. Posting even more isn’t going to help that. In fact, if you can believe some of the conspiracy theories floating around, posting more can cause even more damage. I have no idea if that’s true, but posting more when your content already isn’t being distributed doesn’t make sense to me. In fact, quite the opposite. When my Reels don’t do well, it pushes me to post less because why put work into something that no one is going to see? I’d rather watch TV.

I felt that way about writing and publishing my books, when Reels was my last-ditch effort to find readers, and I may feel like that again, sooner rather than later. Why publish a book when no one is going to know it exists?

People will tell you that you have to want to do those things for yourself first, then anything after that is a bonus. But that can sound trite and condescending, especially if you’ve worked as hard as I have over the past ten years. I was ready to give up, and that time may come again. I can’t say for certain. But, I can tell you one thing, seeing all those negative red numbers and the downward line graphs won’t inspire or encourage me to post more. Not on this blog, and not on Instagram. It does the opposite, and I’m sure it does for many others too. I wish platforms would understand that negative reinforcement doesn’t do what they want it to do and give us actual feedback to improve those sad numbers.

Of course I don’t think we’re owed views. I’ve written about the entitlement of the author community before, but I do think it’s worth saying that it’d be nice if these platforms would stop telling us to create more and then making us feel bad about it when we do. I’m tired of the games. Show my content or leave me alone. I don’t need your insights.


Speaking about books not being read, last week I finished listening to Bitter Love and got it formatted. I wrote the blurb, tweaked the cover I already had made, and ordered a proof. I’ll read that as the final editing step and make any changes that I’ll need, then order one more proof just to make sure I didn’t mess anything up. I’ll sit on it until January and put it up for free on my website for a couple of days like I said I would because I hate breaking promises. The release date is January 26th, 2027, but I always know in the back of my mind something could get in my way (I’m looking at you KDP wanting rights proof for the stock photos on the cover). Still, reading the proof will be the easiest part of the whole thing, and I’m really relieved I’m close to calling that book done. I’m super pleased with how the cover came out, but since I do proper cover reveals on my author website, you’ll have to wait along with everyone else.

The new cover for Rescue Me is coming along. I found a fabulous new background, but KDP keeps printing it too dark. I “overcorrected” so that the colors will show up the way I want them to. The ebook cover will look how I want without that overcorrection. KDP just prints dark and always has, and it takes me a couple of proofs to get the coloring exactly how I want it to look. I ordered four proofs of A Heartache for Christmas, so I’m used to being a perfectionist. Luckily, the proofs are cheap, and I don’t mind paying to know that my covers will look exactly how I want them to look.

Since those two books are almost done, I gave myself permission to start plotting out my Alpine Divorce standalone. I won’t start writing it because I don’t want to stop to read Bitter Love‘s proof, but I should have many pieces in place by the time I’m done with that read-through. I’m in my standalone era, and I’m loving it. There is much less pressure and it’s more fun knowing that all the work, as pleasant as it is, that I have in front of me is only for one book. My Alpine Divorce will be another romantic suspense, but this one is a hockey romance. I did so much research for my Black Ice duet that I didn’t want to let it all go to waste. Anyway, so I’m super excited to start writing a new book, and I guess I’ll put my Black Ice duet out sometime during the 2027-2028 hockey season. I hope to use the excitement in my marketing. Bitter Love‘s release and my backlist will just have to fuel my author career for a bit because I don’t write to publish anymore. Instead, I focus on the joy of the project, and I like being in that mindset a lot.

You might have noticed I have a new author photo on the sidebar! The other ones I was using were five years old, so I dragged my daughter to a park that’s close to our apartment and asked her to torture me for an hour. I think they came out great, and I’m happy to have updated pictures for all my social media. I wrote about it on my author website and you can see more of them here: https://vmrheault.com/2026/11/10/new-author-pictures-and-a-short-update-%f0%9f%8d%82-%f0%9f%93%9a/

That’s all I have for this week. Ignore those analytics if you can.

I’ll keep trying too.

See you next week!


Discover more from Vania Margene Rheault

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply